Product recalls
I think that Americans are a little nutty about safety. The Consumer Product Safety Commission is constantly issuing recalls, particularly of children’s toys and gear. I do believe that some of these recalls are necessary, but I also believe that many people are unduly stressed by them. Recently thousands of toys were recalled because of “high levels of lead” in the paint. I’ve done some research into lead poisoning. I did it because I acquired an old, painted dresser and I wondered if it was covered in lead based paint. I contacted my county health department. That is where I learned that unless the paint is pealing off and someone is eating it in quantity, there is unlikely to be a problem. However they happily sold me a lead paint test kit for a few dollars. I swabbed the dresser and it was clean.
The children who end up with lead poisoning live in old houses with old paint that is flaking and turning into lead dust. There is a difference between being careful about lead and being paranoid. I have declined to get rid of Gleek’s Polly Pockets. She is not in the habit of scratching the paint off and eating it. Even if she were, the supposedly “high” levels of lead in the paint are actually quite low and probably not dangerous in small quantities.
I feel the same way about magnetic toys. A recent article listed them as one of the biggest hazards of the year. Really? I know that the magnets should never be in the hands of small children who might eat them, but is that really a reason to take them out of the hands of every child everywhere? Somehow I think that far more children are endangered and injured by household chemicals than by magnets or minuscule amounts of lead in paint. It is ironic that parents panic about these toy recalls, but will leave toxic cleaners under the sink in the bathroom.
It all boils down to responsibility. I don’t believe that it is the job of the toy manufacturer or the CPSC to keep my children safe. That is my job. I must look at the toys and items in my house and decide whether I consider them a danger to my children. I do read the recall notices, but only rarely does my judgment determine that the recall was essential for my family. I also do not assume that a product is safe merely because it has not been recalled. Nothing is completely safe. Freak accidents happen. An informed parent who judges based on research rather than paranoia, and who supervises appropriately, is the best way to keep kids safe.