Choosing what to wear
This morning Kiki asked me to help her choose which coat to wear to church. In one hand she held her beautiful ankle-length cloak. In the other hand she held a nice corduroy jacket. I knew which one I would prefer her to wear. The jacket was much more appropriate to a church service. I also knew that I did not want to teach her to be a conformist dresser merely for the sake of fitting in. We had some time, so I took the chance to talk through with her the various implications of her choices in how to dress. The conversation went something like this:
Every social situation has rules about what is appropriate to wear. A swimsuit is perfect for the pool, but considered strange at school. There are reasons for the rules. Some of the reasons are about utility. (Baggy clothes drag in the water and make swimming difficult.) Some of the rules are about social conventions, mutually agreed upon norms for what is appropriate and fashionable.
The human brain is set up to categorize and notice things that do not fit the pattern or social norm. When we choose to break the social norm of dressing for a particular situation, we draw attention. The people around us must now decide why we broke the rules and how they feel about it. some of the reactions will be positive and some will be negative. The strength of the reactions will depend upon how far outside the norm we are. The other people also have to adjust their predictions of our behavior based upon how we broke the rules of dressing. We already obviously broke one set of social norms, they now have to decide what other social norms we might consider irrelevant. If they don’t have a referent for our pattern of dressing, then they become nervous or anxious. This is why costumed convention attendees get such a variety of reactions from the non-attendees around them.
After the discussion was over, I looked at Kiki and told her that she is free to break social norms in how she chooses to dress, but she should do so with an awareness of how it affects others around her. I also mentioned that one reason we dress nicely for church is to show respect to God. Kiki decided not to wear the cloak, which would have really stood out. Instead she wore her mushroom earrings ala the Nintendo Mario games, which are still very non-standard for teenage girls at church. I was pleased with her balance of individuality and conformity, but had she chosen to wear the cloak to church, I would have let her. After all, I let Gleek go to church with two bird Christmas ornaments perched on top of her head and that looked way stranger than a cloak would have done.