Getting my son to read
Link has a mental block about reading and writing. He does just fine once he gets started, but he always views the project with dislike. I was therefore, delighted to discover that Link will devour some manga. Give him Kingdom Hearts, Full Metal Alchemist, Naruto, or Pokemon and he’ll sit on the couch reading all afternoon. I responded to this discovery by giving him more manga because I figured that even though there were far more pictures than words, Link was still reading.
This decision of mine was supported by an article in a recent scouting magazine that talked about why boys don’t like to read as much as girls do. According to the article this is because boys are less interested in relationships, feelings, and dilemmas than girls are. Boys are far MORE interested in farts, adventure, fights, and physical humor. Boys also tend to be more visual. There are genres which cater to both interests. Girls can find Anne of Green Gables, Little House on the Prarie, Magic Tree House, Harry Potter, and a plethora of princess or fairy themed books. Boys can find animorphs, manga, comic strips, comic books, and pulp-style adventure stories. Take a look at those two lists. Which list is most likely to be recommended by librarians and teachers? Over and over again boys are told that the kinds of things that they like are not worthwhile. The comic books are snatched from their hands and replaced with Magic Tree House books. Don’t get me wrong. We love Magic Tree House here. Kiki went through them all. So did Gleek. Even Link read a bunch of them, but he did not love them. For Link they were tolerable, even enjoyable, but he would never give up a video game to read Magic Tree House. He regularly does when he has a new manga to read.
So I patted myself on the back for being an enlightened parent and I kept supplying manga. All would be well and good, except that today Link’s teacher confiscated the manga and told Link that in 5th grade he needed to be reading books that were not comics. I’m not upset with the teacher. The teacher is very nice and earnest in his desire to help Link. I love what the teacher has got planned to help Link learn to love reading. But the event has me re-thinking my attitude. There is nothing wrong with Link reading manga. I will continue to supply it, but I also need to help him branch out a little. There is a world of wonderful books out there and most of them do not have pictures. Link doesn’t have to choose to read them, but I do not want him to be intimidated by a page full of nothing but words. The only way I can see for him to overcome that intimidation is through practice. So, I’m going to have to quest to see if I can find some books with no pictures that Link can love. I want to find the book that Link will give up video game time to read. I don’t know if it exists.